People's Topical Library

 New Topic  |  Go to Top  |  Go to Topic  |  Search  |  Log In   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 
 The Simulacra Vs The Claws
Author: Julian L Hawksworth 
Date:   04-17-05 11:06

It is of course, not only in The Simulacra novel that these mechanisms are used instead of people. By implication, these humanoids could replace people in other walks of life, instead of simply being operated for specific purposes by their controllers. In reality of course, modern science is a long way from creating humanoids such as these. Even in Philip K Dick novels, there is normally a mechanism by which these humanoids can be controlled - thus reducing their risk of turning into a threat to people. On the otherhand, is it not the case that the use of Simulacra along with the "Claws" in Second Variety could have been used to bring about a sooner ending to the conflict? Indeed, in the films of "Impostor" and "Screamers", there is the implication that the humanoids and certain types of Claw can behave almost as they choose - rather than being loyal to a series of commands. Even so, most versions of the Claw lack any real ability to make their own decisions - especially the "Screamers" of course. In contrast, as anybody who has enjoyed the excellent Impostor movie will know, the protagonist is a Simulacra which manages to display almost the full range of human emotions - whilst still managing to behave as its makers intended. Half jokingly, would it not have been interesting if a Philip K Dick story had been written in which the Claws and Simulacra were forced into conflct with one another?

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: The Simulacra Vs The Claws
Author: Dosuchin 
Date:   04-17-05 16:25

If the Simulacra perform just like humans, wouldn't the battle between them and the Claws be exactly like "humans vs. Claws"?

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: The Simulacra Vs The Claws
Author: Julian L Hawksworth 
Date:   04-21-05 06:36

You make a point, but remember that Simulacra are controlled by their human masters in most cases. Therefore, if they became involved in a conflict with the Claws - there would be implications for those in charge. In other words, those in control of the Simulacra would have to face the political consquences of their fighting with the Claws. Furthermore, the humans in control would not have to fight and die in combat, knowing that the Simulacra were fighting on their behalf.

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: The Simulacra Vs The Claws
Author: Dosuchin 
Date:   04-23-05 13:39

The Simulacra, like the Claws, could possibly become more intelligent over time. Having the Simulacra revolt against the humans, and leaving them to face the Claws.

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: The Simulacra Vs The Claws
Author: blue_cephalopod 
Date:   05-07-05 20:09

The simulacra are more primitive because they require a factory of humans to make them, and instruct them what to do. The claws were made by americans, using shonerman's artificial brain, designed to to kill humans. They were made in automated underground factories which then designed 4 varieties of robots of its own that were immune to radiation, which the americans used to disable ealier claw types that came near them. The four new varieties were like the simulacras in appearance to gain the trust of humans and be led to bunkers and let more claws in, then kill. The are so convincing to humans on their own because they will even attack other types of claw, and the Second Variety (Tasso) has a bomb designed to kill claws. For some reason they ended up fighting each other when there were no humans left on earth.

Reply To This Message
 Forum List  |  Threaded View   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic